JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES) ›› 2015, Vol. 53 ›› Issue (9): 65-70.doi: 10.6040/j.issn.1671-7554.0.2014.830

Previous Articles     Next Articles

Comparison of nephron-sparing surgery and radical nephrectomy for T1b renal cell carcinoma: a Meta-analysis

SU Jing1, XUE Jiaomei1, SUN Feifei1, GUO Zhaoxin2, CHENG Xiangyu2, MENG Liwei2, LIU Zhaoxu2   

  1. 1. School of Nursing, Shandong University, Jinan 250012, Shandong, China;
    2. Department of Urology, Qilu Hospital of Shandong University, Jinan 250012, Shandong, China
  • Received:2014-11-17 Online:2015-09-10 Published:2015-09-10
  • Contact: 刘照旭。E-mail:zhaoxvliu@sdu.edu.cn E-mail:zhaoxvliu@sdu.edu.cn

PDF (PC)

249

Abstract: Objective To compare the outcomes of nephron-sparing surgery (NSS) and radical nephrectomy (RN) in treating T1b renal cell carcinoma (RCC). Methods The following databases including Pubmed, Elsevier ScienceDirect, Web of Science, Co-chrane library, CNKI, CBM, VIP and WanFang were searched electronically from the date of their establishment to Sept. 2014 to collect cohort studies on NSS versus RN in the treatment of T1b RCC, and the references of those studies were manually retrieved. After the studies were screened according to the inclusion and exclusion criteria, data were extracted and assessed, and Meta-analysis was performed using the Stata 12.0 software. Results A total of 11 studies with 23,939 patients were included. The Results of Meta-analyses showed that, RN and NSS had no significant difference in 5-year[RR=1.05, 95% CI(0.98, 1.13)], 7-year [RR=1.02, 95% CI (0.94, 1.10)], and 10-year [RR=1.30, 95% CI (0.96, 1.77)] overall survival (OS). Nevertheless, NSS had higher 5-year cancer specific survival (CSS) [RR=1.11, 95% CI (1.06, 1.16)], lower 5-year cancer specific mortality (CSM) [RR=0.70, 95% CI (0.55, 0.90)] and lower metastasis rate [RR=0.38, 95% CI(0.22, 0.66)]. Conclusion For the patients who are included in the study, NSS and RN is comparable in 5-year OS, 7-year OS, 10-year OS; NSS is superior to RN in 5-year CSS, 5-year CSM and metastasis rate.

Key words: T1b RCC, Prognosis, Radical nephrectomy, Nephron-sparing surgery, Meta-analysis

CLC Number: 

  • R737.11
[1] Gupta K, Miller JD, Li JZ, et al. Epidemiologic and socioeconomic burden of metastatic renal cell carcinoma (mRCC):a literature review[J]. Cancer Treat Rev, 2008, 34(3):193-205.
[2] Silverman SG, Israel GM, Herts BR, et al. Management of the incidental renal mass[J]. Radiology, 2008, 249(1):16-31.
[3] Milonas D, Skulcius G, Baltrimavicius R, et al. Comparison of long-term results after nephron-sparing surgery and radical nephrectomy in treating 4-to 7-cm renal cell carcinoma[J]. Medicina (Kaunas), 2013, 49(5):223-228.
[4] 王权, 周文生. 小肾癌的治疗策略[J]. 中华全科医学, 2010, 8(12):1590-1592.
[5] Tomaszewski JJ, Smaldone MC, Uzzo RG, et al. Is radical nephrectomy a legitimate therapeutic option in patients with renal masses amenable to nephron-sparing surgery?[J]. BJU Int, 2015, 115(3):357-363.
[6] Antonelli A, Cozzoli A, Nicllai M, et al. Nephron-sparing surgery versus radical nephrectomy in the treatment of intracapsular renal cell carcinoma up to 7cm[J]. Eur Urol, 2008, 53(4):803-809.
[7] Wells G, Shea B, O'Connell D, et al. The Newcastle-Ottawa Scale (NOS) for assessing the quality of nonrandomised studies in meta-analyses [EB/OL]. [2012-06-15]. http://www.ohri.ca/programs/clinical_epidemiology/oxford.asp.
[8] Badalato GM, Kates M, Wisnivesky JP, et al. Survival after partial and radical nephrectomy for the treatment of stage T1bN0M0 renal cell carcinoma (RCC) in the USA:a propensity scoring approach[J]. BJU Int, 2012, 109(10):1457-1462.
[9] Crépel M, Jelares C, Perrotte P, et al. Nephron-sparing surgery is equally effective to radical nephrectomy for T1BN0M0 renal cell carcinoma:a population-based assessment[J]. Urology, 2010, 75(2):271-275.
[10] Iizuka J, Kondo T, Hashimoto Y, et al. Similar functional outcomes after partial nephrectomy for clinical T1b and T1a renal cell carcinoma[J]. Int J Urol, 2012, 19(11):980-986.
[11] Kim JM, Song PH, Kim HT, et al. Comparison of partial and radical nephrectomy for pT1b renal cell carcinoma[J]. Korean J Urol, 2010, 51(9):596-600.
[12] Leibovich BC, Blute M, Cheville JC, et al. Nephron sparing surgery for appropriately selected renal cell carcinoma between 4 and 7 cm results in outcome similar to radical nephrectomy[J]. J Urol, 2004, 171(3):1066-1070.
[13] Meskawi M, Becker A, Bianchi M, et al. Partial and radical nephrectomy provide comparable long-term cancer control for T1b renal cell carcinoma[J]. Int J Urol, 2014, 21(2):122-128.
[14] Patard JJ, Shvarts O, Lam JS, et al. Safety and efficacy of partial nephrectomy for all T1 tumors based on an international multicenter experience[J]. J Urol, 2004, 171(6):2181-2185.
[15] Thompson RH, Siddiqui S, Lohse CM, et al. Partial versus radical nephrectomy for 4 to 7 cm renal cortical tumors[J]. J Urol, 2009, 182(6):2601-2606.
[16] Weight CJ, Larson BT, Gao T, et al. Elective partial nephrectomy in patients with clinical T1b renal tumors is associated with improved overall survival[J]. Urology, 2010, 76(3):631-637.
[17] 胡波, 王涛, 刘继红,等. 保留肾单位手术和肾癌根治手术治疗局限性肾癌疗效比较的Meta分析[J]. 临床泌尿外科杂志, 2011, 26(5):324-327. HU Bo, WANG Tao, LIU Jihong, et al. Comparison of nephron-sparing surgery vs.radical phrectomy in patients with localized renal cell carcinoma:a Meta-analysis[J]. Journal of clinical Urology, 2011, 26(5):324-327.
[18] Kim SP, Murad MH, Thompson RH, et al. Comparative effectiveness for survival and renal function of partial and radical nephrectomy for localized renal tumors:a systematic review and Meta-analysis[J]. J Urol, 2012,188(1):51-57.
[19] Lucas SM, Stern JM, Adibi M, et al. Renal function outcomes in patients treated for renal masses smaller than 4 cm by ablative and extirpative techniques[J]. J Urol, 2008, 179(1):75-79.
[20] Lane BR, Russo P, Uzzo RG, et al. Comparison of cold and warm ischemia during partial nephrectomy in 660 solitary kidneys reveals predominant role of nonmodifiable factors in determining ultimate renal function[J]. J Urol, 2011, 185(2):421-427.
[21] Miller DC, Schonlau M, Litwin MS, et al. Renal and cardiovascular morbidity after partial or radical nephrectomy[J]. Cancer, 2008, 112(3):511-520.
[22] 郑殿宇, 王勤章, 丁国富, 等. 肾部分切除术和肾癌根治术治疗T1b期肾癌疗效比较的Meta分析[J]. 现代泌尿外科杂志, 2013, 18(4):342-346. ZHENG Dianyu, WANG Qinzhang, DING Guofu, et al. Comparison of partial vs radical nephrectomy in patients with T1b renal cell carcinoma:a Meta-analysis[J]. Journal of Modern Urology, 2013, 18(4):342-346
[1] LI Yinglin, SONG Daoqing, XU Zhonghua. Identification of FKBP11 expression in clear cell renal cell carcinoma using bioinformatics analysis [J]. Journal of Shandong University (Health Sciences), 2020, 1(9): 45-51.
[2] SHI Shuang, LI Juan, MI Qi, WANG Yunshan, DU Lutao, WANG Chuanxin. Construction and application of a miRNAs prognostic risk assessment model of gastric cancer [J]. Journal of Shandong University (Health Sciences), 2020, 1(7): 47-52.
[3] LI Xingkai, LIU Zhanye, JIANG Yunfeng, LI Jun. Clinicopathological factors and prognosis between primary central and peripheral lung squamous cell carcinoma [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2017, 55(9): 73-78.
[4] LIN Pingzhen, XUE Jiaomei, YANG Bei, LI Meng, ZHOU Mailin, CAO Fenglin. Correlation between posttraumatic growth and psychological adjustment of cancer survivors based on Pearson correlation coefficient: a Meta-analysis [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2017, 55(9): 110-121.
[5] ZONG Shuai, XIAO Dongjie, LIU Hua, JIA Yanfei, MA Xiaoli, LI Huanjie, LI Ping, ZHENG Yan, WANG Yunshan. Expression of CSN5 and its correlation with the prognosis of gastric carcinoma [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2017, 55(7): 12-16.
[6] DU Jinge, CHEN Hui, YANG Xiaorong, LÜ Ming. Meta-analysis of the association between the STAT4 rs7574865 polymorphism and systemic lupus erythematosus [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2017, 55(5): 95-102.
[7] SUN Qijing, CHEN Fangfang, LI Chunxiao, ZHANG Caiqing. Clinical value of PNI and HGB in evaluating the prognosis of the middle to late stage non-small cell lung cancer patients [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2017, 55(4): 55-59.
[8] LIN Jiaxiang, GUO Zijia, SU Peng, WANG Xiao, GUO Yaxin, WU Xiaojuan, XIANG Lei, ZHOU Zhiqiang, WANG Yan, CUI Xiujie, PAN Aifeng, GUO Chenghao. The role of CIP2A in the transformation of breast ductal epithelium and prognosis of invasive breast cancer [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2017, 55(3): 100-106.
[9] ZHOU Lanlan, PAN Xueyi, GUO Yu. Clinical characteristics and prognosis of 48 patients with mixed phenotype acute leukemia [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2017, 55(2): 79-83.
[10] ZHANG Xiying, ZHAI Chunyan, LI Jingsong, HAN Bo. Expression of EZH2 in Chinese Ewing sarcoma patients and its relationship with clinicopathological parameters and prognosis [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2017, 55(2): 84-91.
[11] LIU Huiling, WANG Xingwen, FENG Shaobin, FENG Hong, HAN Junqing. Association between high expression of scavenger receptor class B type I and the prognosis of colon cancer [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2017, 55(10): 84-89.
[12] WANG Lili, HUO Bin, WANG Lei, WANG Hao, HOU Dingkun, HUO Xiaodong, WANG Jinhuan, ZANG Li, CAO Qiang, CHAI Shude, WANG Haitao. Meta-analysis and system evaluation of 125I implantation in the treatment of early lung cancer [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2017, 55(10): 76-83.
[13] LI Xiaoning, CUI Lianqun. Treatment timing of non-infarct-related artery in patients with multi-vessel disease and acute myocardial infarction [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2016, 54(8): 50-54.
[14] WANG Wen, LIU Yao, LONG Fei, MA Weixia, SU Lili. Correlation between lymphocyte-to-monocyte ratio in peripheral blood and prognosis of malignant pleural mesothelioma [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2016, 54(8): 72-77.
[15] LIU Tong, ZHANG Xin, WANG Chuanxin. Significance of IRX5 mRNA in the diagnosis and prognosis of colorectal cancer [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2016, 54(7): 69-74.
Viewed
Full text


Abstract

Cited
  Shared   
  Discussed   
No Suggested Reading articles found!
Copyright 2018 © Editorial office of Journal of Shandong University (Health Sciences)
Supported by Beijing Magtech Co.Ltd