Journal of Shandong University (Health Sciences) ›› 2021, Vol. 59 ›› Issue (1): 28-33.doi: 10.6040/j.issn.1671-7554.0.2020.0686

Previous Articles     Next Articles

Comparison of efficacy of gamma knife radiosurgery and microvascular decompression in the treatment of primary trigeminal neuralgia

WANG Liangliang1, ZHANG Ming1, SUN Zhenwei1, DING Shouluan2, FAN Yuefei1, WANG Chengwei1   

  1. 1. Department of Neurosurgery;
    2. Center of Evidence-Based Medicine, The Second Hospital, Cheeloo College of Medicine, Shandong University, Jinan 250033, Shandong, China
  • Published:2021-01-09

PDF (PC)

152

Abstract: Objective To compare the efficacy and safety of gamma knife surgery(GKS)and microvascular decompression(MVD)for primary trigeminal neuralgia(PTN). Methods A total of 76 patients with PTN were included in this study since 2016(GKS: 40 cases, MVD: 36 cases). The maximum follow-up lasted for 40 months. The efficacy and complication rate of the two treatment methods were evaluated with t-test and Wilcoxon signed rank sum test. Results The difference between preoperative and postoperative BNI was statistically significant(GKS: Z=-5.069, P<0.001; MVD: Z=-5.292, P<0.001). The pain relief effect time after GKS was significantly longer than that after MVD ［GKS:(75.00±115.50)days; MVD:(2.0±0.00)days］, and the difference was statistically significant(U=248.5, P<0.001). There was significant difference in the degree of pain relief between the MVD group and GKS group(U=500, P=0.013). The complication rate of MVD(38.9%)was higher than that of GKS(20.0%), but the difference was not statistically significant(χ2=3.287, P=0.070). There was statistically significant difference in the costs ［GKS:(12 236±1 831)yuan, MVD:(37 671±5 221)yuan, U=2.0, P<0.001］. Conclusion Both GKS and MVD are effective measures in the treatment of PTN. MVD can obtain immediate pain relief but it has higher surgical risks and costs than GKS. As a safe and minimally invasive treatment, GKS takes a long time for pain relief. Individualized, comprehensive treatment plans should be developed according to the specific conditions of patients.

Key words: Gamma knife, Microvascular decompression, Trigeminal neuralgia, Radiosurgery

CLC Number: 

  • R651.1+9
[1] Tuleasca C, Regis J, Sahgal A, et al. Stereotactic radiosurgery for trigeminal neuralgia: a systematic review [J]. J Neurosurg, 2018, 130(3): 733-757.
[2] Zeng Y, Zhang H, Yu S, et al. Efficacy and safety of microvascular decompression and gamma knife surgery treatments for patients with primary trigeminal neuralgia: a prospective study [J]. World Neurosurg, 2018, 116: e113-e117. doi: 10.1016/j.wenu.2018.04.120
[3] Ertiaei A, Ataeinezhad Z, Bitaraf M, et al. Application of an artificial neural network model for early outcome prediction of gamma knife radiosurgery in patients with trigeminal neuralgia and determining the relative importance of risk factors [J]. Clin Neurol Neurosurg, 2019, 179: 47-52. doi: 10.1016/j.clineuro.2018.11.007.
[4] Barker FG 2nd, Jannetta PJ, Bissonette DJ, et al. The long-term outcome of microvascular decompression for trigeminal neuralgia [J]. N Engl J Med, 1996, 334(17): 1077-1083.
[5] Sarsam Z, Garcia-Finana M, Nurmikko TJ, et al. The long-term outcome of microvascular decompression for trigeminal neuralgia [J]. Br J Neurosurg, 2010, 24(1): 18-25.
[6] Rogers CL, Shetter AG, Fiedler JA, et al. Gamma knife radiosurgery for trigeminal neuralgia: the initial experience of the barrow neurological institute [J]. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys, 2000, 47(4): 1013-1019.
[7] Sharma R, Phalak M, Katiyar V, et al. Microvascular decompression versus stereotactic radiosurgery as primary treatment modality for trigeminal neuralgia: a systematic review and meta-analysis of prospective comparative trials [J]. Neurol India, 2018, 66(3): 688-694.
[8] Brisman R. Microvascular decompression vs. gamma knife radiosurgery for typical trigeminal neuralgia: preliminary findings [J]. Stereotact Funct Neurosurg, 2007, 85(2-3): 94-98.
[9] Linskey ME, Ratanatharathorn V, Penagaricano J. A prospective cohort study of microvascular decompression and Gamma Knife surgery in patients with trigeminal neuralgia [J]. J Neurosurg, 2008, 109(Suppl): 160-172. doi:10.3171/JNS/2008/109/12/S25.
[10] Pollock BE, Schoeberl KA. Prospective comparison of posterior fossa exploration and stereotactic radiosurgery dorsal root entry zone target as primary surgery for patients with idiopathic trigeminal neuralgia [J]. Neurosurgery, 2010, 67(3): 633-638.
[11] Wang DD, Raygor KP, Cage TA, et al. Prospective comparison of long-term pain relief rates after first-time microvascular decompression and stereotactic radiosurgery for trigeminal neuralgia [J]. J Neurosurg, 2018, 128(1): 68-77.
[12] Berger I, Nayak N, Schuster J, et al. Microvascular decompression versus stereotactic radiosurgery for trigeminal neuralgia: a decision analysis [J]. Cureus, 2017, 9(1): e1000. doi:10.7759/cureus.1000.
[13] 欧阳禹权, 石涛涛, 魏俊怀, 等. 微血管减压术与伽玛刀治疗原发性三叉神经痛疗效的Meta分析[J]. 中国微侵袭神经外科杂志, 2020, 25(2):62-67. OUYANG Yuquan, SHI Taotao, WEI Junhuai, et al. Meta-analysis of the efficacy of microvascular decompression and gamma knife for primary trigeminal neuralgia [J]. Chinese Journal of Minimally Invasive Neurosurgery, 2020, 25(2): 62-67.
[14] Nanda A, Javalkar V, Zhang S, et al. Long term efficacy and patient satisfaction of microvascular decompression and gamma knife radiosurgery for trigeminal neuralgia [J]. J Clin Neurosci, 2015, 22(5): 818-822.
[15] Panczykowski DM, Jani RH, Hughes MA, et al. Development and evaluation of a preoperative trigeminal neuralgia scoring system to predict long-term outcome following microvascular decompression [J]. Neurosurgery, 2019, 87(1): 71-79
[16] Sindou M, Leston J, Decullier E, et al. Microvascular decompression for primary trigeminal neuralgia: long-term effectiveness and prognostic factors in a series of 362 consecutive patients with clear-cut neurovascular conflicts who underwent pure decompression [J]. J Neurosurg, 2007, 107(6): 1144-1153.
[17] Miller JP, Magill ST, Acar F, et al. Predictors of long-term success after microvascular decompression for trigeminal neuralgia [J]. J Neurosurg, 2009, 110(4): 620-626.
[18] Inoue T, Hirai H, Shima A, et al. Long-term outcomes of microvascular decompression and Gamma Knife surgery for trigeminal neuralgia: a retrospective comparison study [J]. Acta Neurochir(Wien), 2017, 159(11): 2127-2135.
[19] Kondziolka D, Lunsford LD, Flickinger JC, et al. Stereotactic radiosurgery for trigeminal neuralgia: a multiinstitutional study using the gamma unit [J]. J Neurosurg, 1996, 84(6): 940-945.
[20] Matsuda S, Serizawa T, Nagano O, et al. Comparison of the results of 2 targeting methods in Gamma Knife surgery for trigeminal neuralgia [J]. J Neurosurg, 2008, 109(Suppl): 185-189. doi:10.3171/JNS/2008/109/12/S28.
[21] Park SH, Hwang SK, Kang DH, et al. The retrogasserian zone versus dorsal root entry zone: comparison of two targeting techniques of gamma knife radiosurgery for trigeminal neuralgia [J]. Acta Neurochir(Wien), 2010, 152(7): 1165-1170.
[22] Xu Z, Schlesinger D, Moldovan K, et al. Impact of target location on the response of trigeminal neuralgia to stereotactic radiosurgery [J]. J Neurosurg, 2014, 120(3): 716-724.
[23] Zhao H, Shen Y, Yao D, et al. Outcomes of two-isocenter gamma knife radiosurgery for patients with typical trigeminal neuralgia: pain response and quality of life [J]. World Neurosurg, 2018, 109: e531-e538. doi: 10.1016/j.wneu.2017.10.014.
[24] Spina A, Boari N, Gagliardi F, et al. Gamma knife radiosurgery for trigeminal neuralgia: when? [J]. Neurosurg Rev, 2019, 42(2): 599-601.
[25] Regis J, Tuleasca C, Resseguier N, et al. Long-term safety and efficacy of Gamma Knife surgery in classical trigeminal neuralgia: a 497-patient historical cohort study [J]. J Neurosurg, 2016, 124(4): 1079-1087.
[26] 王宏昭, 焦峻峰, 马琳, 等. 显微血管减压术与伽玛刀治疗老年原发性三叉神经痛近期疗效的对比分析 [J]. 中国微侵袭神经外科杂志, 2019, 24(7): 307-309. WANG Hongzhao, JIAO Junfeng, MA Lin, et al. Comparative analysis of the short term efficacy of microvascular decompression and gjamma knife in the treatment of eldly patients with idiopathic trigeminal neuralgia[J]. Chinese Journal of Minimally Invasive Neurosurgery, 2019, 24(7): 307-309.
[1] GAO Zhongxia, ZHANG Ming, FAN Mingde, TAN Chenyang, WANG Mengdi, WANG Chao, FAN Yuefei, DING Shouluan, WANG Chengwei. Efficacy and prognostic factors of gamma knife in treating 81 cases of brain metastases from lung cancer [J]. Journal of Shandong University (Health Sciences), 2022, 60(8): 44-49.
[2] GUO Wenqiang, JIANG Bin, HE Zheng, HUANG Dezhang, ZHANG Hongying, YIN Xin, WANG Zhigang. Clinical analysis of microvascular decompression in 48 patients with hemifacial spasm [J]. Journal of Shandong University (Health Sciences), 2020, 58(11): 59-64.
[3] ZHANG Bin, ZHANG Liangwen, CHI Lingyi, WANG Chuanwei, ZHU Shugan. Influencing factors on the curative effect of microvascular decompression in the treatment of primary trigeminal neuralgia [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2016, 54(6): 69-72.
[4] FENG Zichao, WANG Jiwei, LI Chao, LI Weiguo, CHEN Teng, MA Xiangyu, XU Shujun, LI Xingang. Role of pure neuroendoscopy in cerebellopontine angle area surgery [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2016, 54(10): 71-75.
[5] WANG Jiwei, LI Chao, CHEN Teng, ZHANG Wenhua, LI Weiguo, MA Xiangyu, XU Shujun, LI Xingang. Simple endoscopic vascular decompression in the treatment of trigeminal neuralgia [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2015, 53(4): 83-86.
[6] XU Ran, MA Xiangyu, LI Weiguo, LI Chao, ZHANG Xin, XU Shujun, LI Xingang. Neuroendoscopic microvascular decompression for hemifacial spasm through retrosigmoid key hole approach [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2015, 53(10): 55-57.
[7] HAN Jie1, LIU Yi-qing1, REN Yan-yan2, LUAN De-heng1, GAO Kun1, XIE Feng-yang1. Changes of substance P and betaEndorphin in the brain of  rats with trigeminal neuralgia [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2013, 51(8): 45-48.
[8] ZHOU Ting-fa1, TANG Zhen-shen2. Effect of dexmedetomidine on general anesthesia in
hypertensive patients undergoing craniectomy [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2012, 50(8): 81-.
[9] ZHANG Liang-wen, WANG Ping, LI Feng, YANG Yang, ZHU Shu-gan. Treatment of primary trigeminal neuralgia by microvascular  decompression: report of 142 cases [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2011, 49(3): 99-101.
[10] ZHANG Liang-wen, WANG Ping, LI Feng, YANG Yang, ZHU Shu-gan. Treatment of primary trigeminal neuralgia by microvascular  decompression: report of 142 cases [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2011, 49(3): 99-101.
[11] WANG Lei,XU Shu-jun,ZHOU Mao-de,JIANG Yu-quan. Neuronavigatio-guided percutaneous radio-frequency thermo-coagulation in treatment of intractable trigeminal neuralgia [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2007, 45(9): 965-967.
Viewed
Full text


Abstract

Cited
  Shared   
  Discussed   
[1] YU Hui1,2, CHEN Shaohua1, ZHAO Jiajun2, GAO Ling3
. Effects of ethanol on glycogen content, GSK3β，
and PAMPK of L02 cells[J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2009, 47(04): 75 -78 .
[2] ZENG Ji-ping,WANG Li-na,WANG Li-xiang,REN Xiao-hui,ZHANG Meng-ye,XIA Wen,CUI Xing. [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2006, 44(5): 467 -470 .
[3] SHU Ya,QI Feng. Jaw thrust device (JTD) on obesity patients for maintaining the airway patency during general anesthesia induction[J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2007, 45(10): 1072 -1074 .
[4] WANG Huan-liang,SUN Bao-zhu,DU Hong-mei,ZHOU Chang-qing,ZHANG Li. Controlling the depth of propofol anesthesia using the bispectral indexand the systolic blood pressure[J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2006, 44(5): 471 -474 .
[5] HUANGQing,TIAN Hui,LI Lin,LIANG Fei,LIU Xi-xian. [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2006, 44(6): 556 -559 .
[6] ZHU Mei-jia,HAN Ju,WANG Xin-yi,LU Wei,WANG Ai-hua,GUAN Xin-hua,CAO Xia,CAO Bing-zhen. [J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2006, 44(8): 834 -839 .
[7] SONG Hai-yan, WU Yu-ling, ZHANG Yan-ping. Protective effect of oyster extract on apoptotic cells in neural tube defect induced by hyperthermia[J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2007, 45(2): 113 -116 .
[8] ZHAO Zheng-bin1， XUE Shuang-lin2， ZHANG Li-ting1， LI Jun-feng1，ZHAO Rong-rong1， ZHOU Hai-lian3， CHEN Hong1. Effects of procyanidins on the proliferation of hepatic stellate cells and production of TIMP-1 induced by leptin[J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2012, 50(7): 46 .
[9] WANG Zhi-ang,DING Xua,SUN Peng/sup>,WANG Cheng-wei,HAO Xiao-guang,PAN Shun. Role of pre-operative cerebral angiography in cerebral artery stenosis stent angioplasty[J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2007, 45(2): 146 -148 .
[10] MENG Jing1，LIU Xiao-li2，GUO Chun3，MA Chun-hong3. Construction of the mouse T cell immunoglobulin mucin 3(Tim-3) eukaryotic expression vector[J]. JOURNAL OF SHANDONG UNIVERSITY (HEALTH SCIENCES), 2010, 48(11): 37 -40 .
Copyright 2018 © Editorial office of Journal of Shandong University (Health Sciences)
Supported by Beijing Magtech Co.Ltd